20.12.11

'Tree of Life' directed by Terrence Malick.

Produced by: Dede Gardner, Sarah Green, Grant Hill, Brad Pitt, and Bill Pohlad.
Written by: Terrence Malick.
Starring: Brad Pitt, Sean Penn, and Jessica Chastain.
Year of release: 2011.
Run Time: 139 minutes.
Budget: $32 Million.
Gross Revenue: $54, 246, 069. 



“The nuns taught us that there are two ways through life- the way of nature and the way of grace. You have to choose which one you’ll follow. Grace doesn’t try to please itself, accepts being slighted, forgotten, disliked, accepts insults and injuries. Nature only wants to please itself. Get others to please it too. Likes to lord it over them. To have its own way. It finds reasons to be unhappy when all the world shines around it, and love is smiling through all things.” Jessica Chastain’s Mrs. O’Brien informs us in voice over at the beginning of Tree of Life, and we the audience know that it is in for something special.

This movie was my second experience of Terrence Malick’s exceptional writing/direction, the first being The Thin Red Line, which is often unfairly compared unfavourably with Saving Private Ryan due to the proximity of its release to Spielberg’s war epic. I’m happy to report that Tree of Life is a stunning film—one of those classic films that inspired me to start writing a blog about film in the first place. Not only is it visually intriguing, and riveting dramatically, it also connects two ideas that have too long stood unrelated in the general zeitgeist: the relationship between the evolution of species and human behaviour.

If I were to recommend a companion book for this movie, it would certainly be Richard Dawkins’ The Selfish Gene. This book is a consciousness shifter, the kind that changes your entire view on life after you read it. If you have ever found yourself pondering why humans behave the way they do, then let me assure you that The Selfish Gene provies an answer, and indeed the answer to that timeless question of the meaning of life. And if The Selfish Gene provides the answer, then Malick’s Tree of Life certainly extends the reach of the book well into human psychology, attempting to explain human nature through a scientific lens. Is it successful? Probably not as much as it could have been if the run-time was extended by another two hours, but Tree of Life still stands as one of the most thought provoking films of 2011 (it is perhaps bested by Lars Von Trier’s Melancholia, which I shall endeavour to review at some point).

When I say that Malick attempts to explain human psychology via a scientific lens, I suppose you’d be forgiven for thinking that the film is a cold consideration of humanity, much like Steven Soderbergh’s Contagion. It is a sad fact that most people quickly associate the word ‘scientific’ with words like ‘cold’, ‘sterile’, and ‘non-living’. When the grandiose and beautiful reality of biology on Earth is considered, science is quickly transformed into something that is warm and wonderful (though sometimes cruel indeed). Tree of Life is filled with such warmth, and such insight into what it is like to be a human, that you'd be a pretty hard individual to not be at least a little moved by it. It successfully manages to marry the depth of human emotion with the scientific crane of evolution by natural selection in a way that would make Richard Dawkins proud.

By now, you’re probably aware that the film doesn’t follow a linear narrative path, but rather presents fragments of narrative through stunning images. This is certainly true in the first half of the film, which leads up to the much lauded montage of the big bang, right on past the evolution of simple life forms, to the extinction of the dinosaurs. After this however, Malick explores the life of the O’Brien family much more comprehensively, though altogether natural and realistic. You get the sense that you are actually witnessing real lives, as opposed to characters, and scenes where the boys of the film put themselves in danger cause a primitive emotional response; you wish you could reach into the film and tell them to stop doing what they are doing.

The film is marred a little in the last twenty-minutes, where it kind of meanders off and doesn’t really make much sense (at least not to me), but ultimately Malick achieves something that no other film-maker has; a vision that is beautiful and utterly unique. Is this not more than we can ask for as an audience of cinema? Though Tree of Life might not change your outlook on life completely, its ideas will stay with you pleasantly for weeks. It's also one of those movies (much like 2001: A Space Odyssey) that's going to be interpreted and reinterpreted for years. I thoroughly recommend this one.


                                               Four-and-a-half stars:

16.12.11

'The Ledge' directed by Mathew Chapman.

‘The Ledge’ directed by Mathew Chapman.
Produced by: Michael Mailer, Mark Damon and Mathew Chapman.
Written by: Mathew Chapman.
Starring: Charlie Hunnam, Terrence Howard, Liv Tyler and Patrick Wilson.
Release date: January 21st, 2011 (Sundance)
Budget: $10 Million.


When I first saw the trailer for this movie, I thought that it could be interesting. It’s essentially a thriller based around the conflict between religion and atheism, a debate which has grown in popularity since Richard Dawkins published The God Delusion and subsequently released a bee in the bonnet of pretty much anyone that takes the concept of faith seriously. I think there are a lot of people out there tapping away on keyboards that are all too ready to proudly take a position on the issue. All you need to do is sign up to an internet message board and hang around for a while before an atheism/religion argument pops up. I’m not saying that it’s not an important debate (it’s probably the most important), I guess what I’m trying to say is that there are too many people out there in cyberspace that are arguing the issue just for the sake of arguing (this is true of both sides). For the record I’m an atheist, and for one more record, I’m not a physicist or a biologist that has dedicated my life to the pursuit of answering the big questions. So for the remainder of this review, I’m gonna do what it is people who aren’t physicists or biologists should do when it comes to questions about reality: Shut the fuck up.

As an atheist, however, I was interested to see how the The Ledge would unfold. I went in expecting heated drama motivated by two opposing views of life. What I got was an unconvincing mess of a film that was, at the best, clichéd to the point that it was laughable, and at the worst, more pretentious than your average Mac owner.  It appears that Chapman (writer/director) has written the script with a copy of The God Delusion at his side, and simply shoe-horned each argument into his plot. Whilst this is not necessarily enough to make the film shit, Chapman solved that problem by injecting his movie full of the over-dramatic cheese that only Americans seem to be capable of.

An example of this? Well, The Ledge has its damsel-in-distress in the form of Liv Tyler’s character Shana, a devoutly religious woman who is married to the worst kind of alpha-male—the one that has received a higher calling from Yaweh himself. Why is Shana religious? Because she used to be a prostitute and one of her johns had a church fetish: he liked to have sex prostitutes inside churches and then beat them up. This is no joke folks, Liv Tyler tells us so in the second act. When she says it, the first thing I wondered was how the hell you have sex inside a church without anyone noticing. The second thing I wondered was just how obvious the whole backstory was. This is the kind of writing you’d expect from a tenth grade emo kid’s creative writing assessment. The kind the teacher probably laughed at, but ultimately gave an A+ because all the other kids wrote about what they did in the summer break.

Another problem I had was that none of the characters were likeable. Indeed if film is a dessert that we enjoy after the main course that is our daily life, then The Ledge is arse-hole pie. The atheist protagonist makes it his mission to seduce Shana just because he feels like he needs to liberate her from the puritanical leash of her husband, not because he likes her or anything, just to make a patronising point. Indeed women should be mad at Shana’s characterisation here. She’s basically a fuck-puppet that gets passed from one douche-bag to another douche-bag without so much as complaining about her role in the warped power play. Of course, it’s okay to have unlikeable characters in film. There Will Be Blood had a bastard of a protag, and it’s one of the greatest films ever made. The characters that inhabit The Ledge just aren’t developed well enough. A few of them achieve character arcs, but they are uninteresting and utterly contrived. I think it took two scenes of Terrence Howard’s whole rocky family situation before I just didn’t give a shit anymore.

And the ending sucked. I won’t give it away and spoil it for those out there that want to see it, but suffice to say Terrence Howard has what is quite possibly the most retarded Eureka! moment ever recorded on film.

One star:

9.7.11

'Gnomeo and Juliet' directed by Kelly Asbury.

Produced by: Baker Bloodworth, David Furnish, Steve Hamilton Shaw and Elton John.
Written by: John R. Smith, Rob Sprackling, Kelly Asbury, Mark Burton, Andy Riley, Kevin Cecil, Emily Cook, Kathy Greenberg, Steve Hamilton Shaw.
Starring: James McAvoy, Emily Blunt, Michael Kane, Jason Stratham, Maggie Smith, Patrick Stewart and a bunch of other Brits.
Music by: Elton John, Chris P. Bacon and James Newton Howard.
Year of release: 2011.
Budget: $36 Million.
Gross Revenue: $189, 712, 432.



My girlfriend chose this movie when we were in the video-store looking for something to watch. I have a sneaking suspicion that she chose it because she’s halfway through the fifth season of Six Feet Under and just needs a break from all the fucking sadness that seems to permeate every second of that show. Regardless, I didn’t complain too much because the idea of Romeo and Juliet as a computer animated kid’s film intrigued me. I wondered whether or not the titular gnomes would meet the fateful end that garnered the original play its tragedy tagline (the gnomes don’t kill themselves by the way, something which annoyed me a little bit before I realised that suicide is probably a little bit too hectic for kids aged 4-10 to have to confront.)

The music of Elton John worked pretty well for the most part, however I did think that they could have used more of his songs here. I think you get three or four of them, and it’s nice to see how the film-makers fit them into the story, but I was hanging out for Goodbye Yellow Brick Road or Love Lies Bleeding, and instead got the typically clichéd Your Song. Also, Elton John doesn’t actually sing many of the songs; they are covers by artists who by definition (i.e.- not being Elton John) are inferior.

Apart from that, the story is pretty good and the movie actually works as a kind of introduction to the themes of Romeo and Juliet for kids. The best part about the movie however is definitely the gnomes. They are all very cute and they get up to all kinds of gnome mischief, which is what you want to see in a movie like this. Particular favourites include the red gnomes which all run around and say funny things. Also the flamingo was pretty cool.

The movie isn’t all skittles and sunshine though, and if I had of been at the premiere sitting in close proximity to the film’s director, during the credits I would have huffed “Well it was no fucking Pixar Film, that’s for sure!” before I tossed the remainder of my popcorn to the floor and spat on the seat. No, come on, I wouldn’t do that. If I was actually invited to the premiere of a movie, I’d be well chuffed to meet everyone and generally just pleased to get out of the house.

The Good: The constant references to different Shakespeare plays in the same way that various elements of pop. culture are referenced in the Shrek movies. Sure, some of the Shakespeare references are a bit cheap (in the Gnomeo and Juliet universe there is a removalist company called Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Removals), but at least it’s sort of trying. Also Ashley Jenson’s turn as Nanette the frog is really refreshing because she actually tries to be something other than the character she was famous for in Extras. Something which can’t be said for Stephen Merchant, who plays the same character in every fucking thing he’s in.

The Bad: At the beginning of the movie, a gnome comes out and says something along the lines of: “Before we begin the movie, I must read out a long and boring prologue to establish the scene...” He then sets about reading the opening lines from Romeo and Juliet before being booed off stage. It sort of screamed ignorance to me and reminded me of one of those douche bags that everyone knows that says something like: “Shakespeare was ruined for me in school...” whenever the topic turns to Shakespeare, as if anyone gives a shit what you think, you narcissistic cunt.

The Ugly: The gnomes all breathe as though they are just regular humans. There are several scenes where some of them exert themselves and then have to catch their breath, and everything seems to work as though they have organic lungs. Yet whenever they eat, the food clunks as it goes down as if it were rubbing against porcelain. That shit sent a shiver down my spine.

Three stars: